Case #50: A surgical scar


This elderly gentleman underwent a surgical procedure.

Here is a picture of his abdomen.

Photobucket

Question:
1. What surgery was performed for him?
2. What is this incision called?

Mon, 220808 @ 0700

About these ads

32 comments on “Case #50: A surgical scar

  1. Jayne says:

    i have the same scra-it’s from a liver transplant-it’s called a Mercedes Incision

  2. [...] a  blog and another here/sites about liver transplants and the scars…just in case you were wondering what julie will be [...]

  3. Jimbo says:

    ccc, it’s a little too obscene to tell u what BFS stands for but B stands for ‘big’ and S stands for ‘scar’. Got figure out the ‘F’ word yourself. :)

  4. yumei says:

    anne of green gables = anne of the house with green roof =)

  5. ccc says:

    What does BFS stand for?

  6. nila says:

    hmmm still trying to retrieve the link …will send wen i find it…but Gable itself signifies roof-top if i’m not mistaken =)

  7. lsy says:

    Thanks Jimbo:)

  8. moon gal says:

    tq tq happy here
    =p

  9. Jimbo says:

    My guess is nila = moon gal. Not sure where you got the “Gable incision”, nila, but can I have the reference. And yes, you did write ‘roof top’. Sorry for my oversight. A special ‘kudo’ for you too. :)

  10. Jimbo says:

    Ugh, moon gal, which nick did you use when you answered? I don’t see your answer in the list above.

  11. moon gal says:

    i tot i answered roof-top incision?

  12. Jimbo says:

    Answers today (yesterday I didn’t have internet access)

    As suspected, surgeons are as undecided as physicians when it comes to naming their incisions. The evidences are aplenty here.

    The best answer came from lsy:

    1. Surgery on some upper abdominal viscera,most probably liver transplant. Differential diagnosis include-total gastrectomy, bilateral adrenalectomy, reparation for diaphragmatic hiatus, operations on renal??
    2. A chevron(roof top)incision-a modification of the Kocher’s incision, produced a mercedes benz scar.

    In this patient, he underwent a resection of the left lobe of the liver for focal hepatoma. The double kocher’s incision is an ideal incision to reach the upper abdominal viscera.

    The accepted answers for the incision are:

    1. Bilateral subcostal incision (when you don’t know the name of it, just describe it the best you can)
    2. Bilateral Kocher’s incision
    3. Chevron’s incision
    4. ‘Mercedes’ Incision. This one was coined by Sir Roy Calne (read here: http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=2020659)
    5. Roof-top incision (the scar does look like a roof top)

    Unaccepted answers include:
    1. Mercedes Benz incision (Sir Roy only called it a Mercedes Incision)
    2. BFS (as given by Palmdoc ~ but I do agree that is probably the best description of the scar!) :P

    The name, Kocher’s, brings back a lot of memories, not all pleasant; particularly in my medical student days when I was forced to remember his name for all the stuff he did and invented. I first learned of this scar in India and it was named after him. You can read more about Kocher here: http://www.surgeons.org.uk/history-of-surgeons/emil-theodor-kocher.html

    So, this week’s kudos go to: FengY, little~by~little, lsy, peanut, dytia, aiesha, w1, lishun.

    Well done.

  13. w1 says:

    1. possible surgeries include liver resection , liver transplantation, total gastrectomy, pancreatectomy , splenectomy
    2. bilateral subcostal incision

  14. aiesha says:

    Ok Jimbo, here it goes:
    It is a bilateral subcostal (chevron/roof-top) incision with midline extension (Calne or Mercedes Benz incision. Useful in carying out liver transplantation or extensive hepatic resection.

  15. dytiaaurinh says:

    rooftop incision..

    for whipple’s op…

    i think i saw one on thalassemic boy – he said for splenectomy and cholecystectomy (he had cholelithisis and massive spleen.

  16. peanut says:

    Urm..

    1. Whipple’s operation, cholecystectomy & pancreatectomy due to pancreanecrosis

    2. bilateral subcostal incision

  17. SE says:

    1. Hepatectomy? Liver transplant?
    2. Calne / Mercedes Benz incision

  18. lishun says:

    okok then a rooftop incision with a midline extension. for liver transplant. hehe.

  19. nila says:

    Gable incision (also called “roof-top”) – possible liver resection and/or liver transplant

  20. lsy says:

    would like to try:)
    1. Surgery on some upper abdominal viscera,most probably liver transplant. Differential diagnosis include-total gastrectomy, bilateral adrenalectomy, reparation for diaphragmatic hiatus, operations on renal??
    2. A chevron(roof top)incision-a modification of the Kocher’s incision, produced a mercedes benz scar.

  21. Jimbo says:

    Oops, FengY, you are right. I was referring to the ‘H’ test.

  22. FengY says:

    wait, isn’t the confrontation method used to test the visual field instead of the ocular movements?

    Google says it is Mercedes Benz mah.. LOL

  23. Jimbo says:

    You don’t want to venture a diagnosis, aiesha? :)

  24. aiesha says:

    interesting!!!

  25. little~by~little says:

    Liver transplant
    Roof-Top incision

  26. Jimbo says:

    Guys, isn’t the term ‘Mercedes Benz’ for an incision rather glamorous? I bet the incision has been around even before the car came into being. :)

    So, should we call the ‘Confrontation Method’ in assessing the III, IV and VI cranial nerves, the ‘Hyundai’ maneuver? LOL!

    And thank God no one does a ‘Proton” Incision! It would be quite ghastly to make a lion head shaped incision!

  27. yumei says:

    liver something.

    chevron incision. calne extension?

    google and wiki pwnz =)

  28. lishun says:

    i’m gonna agree with keato.

    1. transplant of the liver (just so i don’t copy completely, lol)
    2. mercedes benz incision

    thank you google and dr jimbo for the great pictures!

  29. keato says:

    Mercedez Benz scar. Liver transplant. :P

  30. oyy says:

    mercedes benz incision.

    Open surgery-laparotomy for Hepatectomy or intrahepatic gall stone..etc..

  31. FengY says:

    wow this is hard!

    1. Surgery done on him. Urmm.. repair of diaphragmatic hernia or something else related to the liver, maybe a partial liver resection?

    2. I would have just said a subcostal incision but thanks to Google, I think it is called Chevron(Rooftop) incision with Mercedes Benz extension.

    Just a question, do we still use such surgical access?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s